| As you probably can tell, ZG and Panfan were the Mafia. They won in the same style as the first practice game, although it wasn't quite as passive as before at least.
From the first page, if I didn't know any roles and had to guess, I would think Marchie and Panfan were Mafia. I like ian's vote which followed my advice from the first post, but Marchie seemed to almost discourage doing that. Also, Marchie's reactions to some of the posts early on seemed a bit overly defensive and looked quite like a Mafia leak. However, it's quite hard to tell the difference between that and a mistake from a rookie Townie. These errors are likely what got him lynched, along with ZG's risk to start the voting train on Marchie which worked.
ZG looked like she was following that advice too, but if you pay attention closely, the questions she was asking actually had pretty simple answers that wouldn't really give out more information.
X-3 was probably the most valuable townie, because he was actively questioning ZG in a good amount of spots. Masa had pretty good instincts as well, but may have been more effective by speaking up more often. t3hdarkness made a good effort for his first game, acting up after being semi-passive for the first half of Day 1, but didn't interpret the clues correctly. No worries; experience will help with that.
Day 2 was just... yeah. There was nothing I could do about that besides pray that somebody else would step in, and I found nobody. =/
I'm not starting signups for another game immediately. These things haven't been working out the way I hoped they would, so I'm not sure about continuing it. |