Game vs. Game #1

01-06-2003, 05:40 PM

I decided to do something different.I will pit two games against eachother in terms of graphics,replay value,sound,and gameplay.Then you can all do the same or just say which game you prefer.When people stop posting,I'll count the votes and see who wins.(My vote doesn't count)
The first GvG is...

Super Mario Sunshine vs. Luigi's Mansion!

To begin,graphics...
This is tough.both games pretty much look the same.Mario sunshine has some nice water effects and stuff.But I'll have to say luigi's mansion,being one of the first GCN games and having nice lighting effects.
MS:0 LM:1

Next,sound.LM has one tune that plays almost all through it.I like the little tune,but MS is just better in sound IMO.I really like some of the remixed classic Mario tunes.
MS:1 LM:1

Now,Gameplay.
LM has neat controls that really haven't been tried before.It's fun,and deserves another shot(in a sequel maybe?) but I just like MS better.It's like SM64 but better.And with a water-pack.All the levels are some-what large,and MS has a nice variety of bosses too.There are old-school type mini stages that you play through without your water-pack.It's not really that hard,but after getting used to your waterpack it seems it.LM is just a little too easy IMO.You can easily beat it in a few plays if you really look around,and it even gives you a map.It's fun though,it's like a scavenger hunt.Every room has its little puzzle.But overall,MS prevails.
MS:2 LM:1

And finally,replay value.Neither game has a huge amount of replay value,but I find myself playing MS more than LM.That's good enough for me.
MS:3 LM:1

That's just my opinion. Here's the overall score so far.
LM:0 MS:0
Get voting.

01-06-2003, 06:25 PM

good idea Andross. As much as I would love doing this I never played Luigi's Mansion so can't vote.

A Genius · 01-07-2003, 07:29 AM

SMS

-A Genius (SMS)

01-06-2003, 05:40 PM	#1
ANDROSS Guest Posts: n/a	I decided to do something different.I will pit two games against eachother in terms of graphics,replay value,sound,and gameplay.Then you can all do the same or just say which game you prefer.When people stop posting,I'll count the votes and see who wins.(My vote doesn't count) The first GvG is... Super Mario Sunshine vs. Luigi's Mansion! To begin,graphics... This is tough.both games pretty much look the same.Mario sunshine has some nice water effects and stuff.But I'll have to say luigi's mansion,being one of the first GCN games and having nice lighting effects. MS:0 LM:1 Next,sound.LM has one tune that plays almost all through it.I like the little tune,but MS is just better in sound IMO.I really like some of the remixed classic Mario tunes. MS:1 LM:1 Now,Gameplay. LM has neat controls that really haven't been tried before.It's fun,and deserves another shot(in a sequel maybe?) but I just like MS better.It's like SM64 but better.And with a water-pack.All the levels are some-what large,and MS has a nice variety of bosses too.There are old-school type mini stages that you play through without your water-pack.It's not really that hard,but after getting used to your waterpack it seems it.LM is just a little too easy IMO.You can easily beat it in a few plays if you really look around,and it even gives you a map.It's fun though,it's like a scavenger hunt.Every room has its little puzzle.But overall,MS prevails. MS:2 LM:1 And finally,replay value.Neither game has a huge amount of replay value,but I find myself playing MS more than LM.That's good enough for me. MS:3 LM:1 That's just my opinion. Here's the overall score so far. LM:0 MS:0 Get voting.

01-06-2003, 06:25 PM	#2
Brandon2390 Guest Posts: n/a	good idea Andross. As much as I would love doing this I never played Luigi's Mansion so can't vote.

01-07-2003, 07:29 AM	#3
A Genius Senior Member Join Date: May 2001 Location: Place Posts: 2,657 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	SMS -A Genius (SMS)